Patrick J Nilan

I asked for a review of my zine work. That is what I received. When requesting a review it is important as a buyer to accept that there will be some negative responses. That is very realistic when giving 15 titles the way I did. I had a discussion with the seller after the delivery and he was able... Mostra di più

Patrick is an excellent beta reader. The feedback was thoughtful, honest, and very useful, with clear insight into character arcs, pacing, worldbuilding, and emotional impact. The report highlighted both what was working well and where the manuscript could be strengthened, without being overly negative... Mostra di più

Honest assessment of my current writing level. I suppose that is what is most valued from an honest beta reader. If a story is not working, you expect them to tell you.

Patrick is, what I would say, the perfect beta reader. The line comments in the manuscript were a joy to read, and his report was insightful. It really pointed out discrepancies in the story that I didn't catch. It has been a pleasure, and I will be paying for this service again

Patrick's comments and feedback are extremely informative and well worth the money